Last modified on 3 September 2014, at 04:29

Category:Citadelle of Quebec

It has been proposed to move Category:Citadelle of Quebec to Category:Citadelle de Québec
Reason: See Commons:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive 40#How important is consistency?. As I noted there Citadelle of Quebec is neither French or English. As I noted at the noticeboard there used to be a Category:Citadelle de Québec. Someone set a robot to empty the category, and create . The bot failed to move the old category to the new, preserving the revision history. And the bot failed to leave a {{category redirect}}.

Note: most of the images in the category use "Citadelle de Québec". If that name is not going to be used, because it is not an English name, then the replacement name should be fully in English -- possibly Category:Citadel of Quebec. I am not strongly committed to Category:Citadelle de Québec instead of Category:Citadel of Quebec. But let's have no bastard hybrid names, like . Whatever decision is made the also-ran names should be redirected to the basename. Deletion of the empty categories was a mistake.

There has been a general problem with bots contributing to the improper deletion of categories they emptied, which should have been turned into redirects.

If Category:Citadelle de Québec is to become a redirect, either its full revision history should be restored, or its revision history should be grafted to the beginning of the history of Category:Citadelle of Quebec or Category:Citadel of Quebec. Our categories are in a constant state of flux. The revision history of the earlier category shows the earlier thinking of how things should fit. There is absolutely no justification for obfuscating this information from non-administrators. Geo Swan (talk) 00:18, 23 August 2014 (UTC)
Date: tagged .

Objections and discussion have their place at Category talk:Citadelle of Quebec (two weeks are considered as adequate time for possible objections). See Commons:Rename a category for general information and policy.
  • If the proposed rename is clearly uncontroversial or consensus-decided, place the bot command (see below) at User talk:CommonsDelinker/commands to be handled by SieBot or rename it and move the content manually. If the new destination category exists, you can remove this template, replacing it with {{category redirect|Citadelle de Québec}}.
  • If the proposal is clearly or potentially controversial or requires a broader discussion, you can transfer the discussion to Commons:Categories for discussion (replacing this template with {{subst:cfd}})
  • If the proposal is clearly nonsensical, mistaken or consensually rejected, please remove this template.

Warning: processing period depends on activity of Commons volunteers. Some proposals (especially with unclear reason or too weak support) stay waiting for many months to be handled.

Bot command: {{move cat|Citadelle of Quebec|Citadelle de Québec|reason=See [[Commons:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive 40#How important is consistency?]]. As I noted there ''Citadelle '''''of''''' Quebec'' is neither French ''or'' English. As I noted at the noticeboard there used to be a [[:Category:Citadelle de Québec]]. Someone set a robot to empty the category, and create . The bot failed to move the old category to the new, preserving the revision history. And the bot failed to leave a {{[[:Template:category redirect|category redirect]]}}. <p>Note: most of the images in the category use ''"Citadelle de Québec"''. If that name is not going to be used, because it is not an English name, then the replacement name should be fully in English -- possibly [[:Category:Citadel of Quebec]]. I am not strongly committed to [[:Category:Citadelle de Québec]] instead of [[:Category:Citadel of Quebec]]. But let's have no bastard hybrid names, like . Whatever decision is made the also-ran names should be redirected to the basename. Deletion of the empty categories was a mistake. <p>There has been a general problem with bots contributing to the improper deletion of categories they emptied, which should have been turned into redirects. <p>If [[:Category:Citadelle de Québec]] is to become a redirect, either its full revision history should be restored, or its revision history should be grafted to the beginning of the history of [[:Category:Citadelle of Quebec]] or [[:Category:Citadel of Quebec]]. Our categories are in a constant state of flux. The revision history of the earlier category shows the earlier thinking of how things should fit. There is absolutely no justification for obfuscating this information from non-administrators. [[User:Geo Swan|Geo Swan]] ([[User talk:Geo Swan|<span class="signature-talk">talk</span>]]) 00:18, 23 August 2014 (UTC)}}
Difference in words:
Category:Citadelle of Quebec
+
Category:Citadelle de Québec
Difference in characters:
Category:Citadelle of Quebec
+
Category:Citadelle de Québec

National Historic Site of Canada
 The article Citadelle of Quebec on Wikipedia projects: (en) Citadelle of Quebec ·
(fr) Citadelle de Québec · +/−
Logo du Répertoire canadien des lieux patrimoniaux.svg
Logo du Répertoire canadien des lieux patrimoniaux.svg

Subcategories

This category has the following 19 subcategories, out of 19 total.

Media in category "Citadelle of Quebec"

The following 200 files are in this category, out of 493 total.

(previous 200) (next 200)(previous 200) (next 200)