File:判決令和2年(ワ)第5801号 損害賠償等請求事件.pdf

Go to page
next page →
next page →
next page →

Original file(1,239 × 1,754 pixels, file size: 2.68 MB, MIME type: application/pdf, 35 pages)

Captions

Captions

Tokyo District Court, Judgment of May 24, 2023

Summary edit

Description
日本語: 文藝春秋社が週刊文春(2019年2月28日号)に掲載した大川宏洋のインタビュー記事について、幸福の科学が文藝春秋社と大川宏洋に対して提起した損害賠償等請求訴訟の東京地裁判決。東京地裁は、記事の内容が「真実であると認めることはできない」とし、これを両者の共同不法行為であるとして、大川宏洋と文藝春秋社に対して330万円の損害賠償を命じた。 特に判決は、「結婚強制」について、「過去にしていた結婚は恋愛結婚であり、当該結婚につき強制されたということはなかったにもかかわらず、その後の清水という特定の相手との結婚については強制されたという被告宏洋の供述は、不自然さを否めない」「被告宏洋の供述を直ちに信用することはできない」とし、文藝春秋社に対しても、被告宏洋の過去の結婚歴等から、その発言内容の信用性につき慎重に検討する必要があったというのに、「既に原告から決別している被告宏洋の発言にのみ依拠して本件記事を掲載した」として、裏付け取材をせず記事を掲載した責任を指摘している。
English: Tokyo District Court ruled in a lawsuit filed by Happy Science against Bungeishunju and Hirosi Okawa for damages, etc., in connection with an interview article with Hiroshi Okawa published by Bungeishunju in the February 28, 2019 issue of Bungeishunju's Weekly Bunshun (February 28, 2019). Tokyo District Court ruled that the content of the article "cannot be acknowledged to be true" and, on the grounds that this was a joint tort by the two parties, ordered Hiroshi Okawa and Bungeishunju to pay 3.3 million yen in damages. In particular, the judgment stated that, with regard to "forced marriage," "Although the past marriages were love marriages and there was no such forced marriage, the defendant Hiroshi's statement that he was forced to marry a specific person, Shimizu, is undeniably unnatural" and "The defendant Hiroshi's statement cannot be immediately trusted". The report also pointed out Bungeishunju's responsibility for publishing the article without conducting corroborating interviews, saying that "Bungeishunju published the article relying only on the statement of the defendant Hiroshi, who had already broken off from the plaintiff," when it was necessary to carefully examine the credibility of the statement based on his past marriage history and other factors.
Date
Source https://justice-irh.jp/other/h_bunshun/
Author 東京地方裁判所民事第32部

Licensing edit

Public domain
This work is in the public domain in Japan according to Article 13 of the Copyright Act of Japan, which states that the following shall not form the subject matter of the rights provided for in this Chapter:
  • (i) the Constitution and other laws and regulations;
  • (ii) notifications, instructions, circular notices and the like issued by organs of the State or local public entities, independent administrative organs ("independent administrative organs" means those mentioned in Article 2, paragraph (1) of the Law for General Rules for Independent Administrative Organs (Law No.103, of 1999); the same shall apply hereinafter) or local independent administrative organs ("local independent administrative organs" means those mentioned in Article 2, paragraph (1) of the Law for Local Independent Administrative Organs (Law No.118, of 2003); the same shall apply hereinafter);
  • (iii) judgments, decisions, orders and decrees of law courts, as well as rulings and decisions made by administrative organs in proceedings similar to judicial ones;
  • (iv) translations and compilations, of those materials mentioned in the preceding three items, made by organs of the State or local public entities, independent administrative organs or local independent administrative organs.

English  español  日本語  한국어  português  中文(简体)  中文(繁體)  +/−

File history

Click on a date/time to view the file as it appeared at that time.

Date/TimeThumbnailDimensionsUserComment
current08:22, 7 July 2023Thumbnail for version as of 08:22, 7 July 20231,239 × 1,754, 35 pages (2.68 MB)Cadenza025 (talk | contribs)Uploaded a work by 東京地方裁判所民事第32部 from https://justice-irh.jp/other/h_bunshun/ with UploadWizard

There are no pages that use this file.

Metadata