File talk:Brachial plexus color.svg

Latest comment: 11 years ago by Shawthorn in topic C5 in lateral root of median nerve

C5 in lateral root of median nerve

edit

With regards to the most recent change, does anyone have a reference supporting the presence of C5 in the median nerve and it's lateral root? My source, [1], only includes C6 and C7.

[1] {{cite book|last=Moore|first=Keith L. Moore, Anne M.R. Agur ; in collaboration with and with content provided by Arthur F. Dalley II ; with the expertise of medical illustrator Valerie Oxorn and the developmental assistance of Marion E.|title=Essential clinical anatomy|year=2007|publisher=Lippincott Williams & Wilkins|location=Baltimore, MD|isbn=0-7817-6274-X|pages=430-431|edition=3} Mcstrother (talk) 19:23, 13 June 2012 (UTC)Reply


It does seem to be a mixed bag, looking further into it. Moore's does indeed not list C5 as part of the median nerve, however, my Netter's[2] does list it, along with Tortora[3]. Gray's[4] is more on the fence, noting that it is inconsistently present. And - after a quick Googling - it seems the latest edition of Netter's has moved to a less strong position, also listing C5 as inconsistent. Perhaps on this basis, a footnote of sorts should be added when using the image? Shawthorn (talk) 12:16, 6 February 2013 (UTC)Reply
[2] Netter, Frank H. (2003) Interactive Atlas of Human Anatomy (3rd ed.), New Jersey: ICON Learning Systems ISBN: 1929007159.
[3] Tortora, Gerard J., Derrickson, Bryan (2012) Principles of Anatomy & Physiology (13th ed.), Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN: 978-0470-56510-0.
[4] Drake, Richard. L, Vogl, A. Wayne, Mitchell, Adam W. M. (2009) Gray's Anatomy for Students (2nd ed.), Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone ISBN: 9780443069529.
Return to the file "Brachial plexus color.svg".