File talk:Invasion of Poland-1939.png

Latest comment: 7 years ago by NeutralRusName in topic Remake or delete

Visualization of independent/dependent/occupied countries edit

I would prefere the boundaries of the Protectorate be drawn differently than boundaries of indepent countries. The map looks like the Protectorate was an Axis member, but in reality it was an territory occupied by Nazi Germany. I guess the similar change to be applied to boundaries of then-Soviet republics (Belaruss and Ukraine). --Bob 07:51, 17 November 2006 (UTC)Reply

Also, Italy did not declare war on France right away (not until after the German invasion of France), so claiming that the Italians were at war with the French is wrong, not to mention "Polish Defensive War" is entirely POV. there are much better maps out there that show the division of Poland.
--Jadger 18:26, 16 March 2007 (UTC)Reply

Remake or delete edit

Reasons: 1) Orange is not "Poland". It's "Poland and Danzig". 2) Slovakia must be dark grey (allied with Germany). Protectorat of Czechia must be light grey (occupied). 3) More accurate to replace "Poland-German/Soviet aggression" on "German/Soviet gains" 4) There are already maps of Poland campaign and Poland partition. 5) German advances are not accurate (may be soviet too), slovac not shown. 6) This map is misinforming (looks like Germany and SU advancing in same time). May be call german arrows "german advances 1-17 september" and soviet arrows "soviet advances 17-28 september".--NeutralRusName (talk) 16:17, 4 June 2016 (UTC)Reply

Return to the file "Invasion of Poland-1939.png".