Wikimedia Commons

User:Gikü/wle2016jury

< User:Gikü

Jury members edit

  • Jury 1: Mihail Turculeț (photographer)
  • Jury 2: Vadim Șterbate (photographer)
  • Jury 3: Gheorghe Iordachi (wikipedian)

Accepted to phase 2 edit

see details
 

3 votes edit

2 votes edit

1 vote edit

Final candidates edit

see details
 

By jury 1 edit

  •  
    10.00 (10 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    8.00 (8 / 1)
  •  
    8.00 (8 / 1)
  •  
    7.00 (7 / 1)
  •  
    7.00 (7 / 1)
  •  
    7.00 (7 / 1)
  •  
    6.00 (6 / 1)
  •  
    6.00 (6 / 1)

By jury 2 edit

  •  
    10.00 (10 / 1)
  •  
    10.00 (10 / 1)
  •  
    10.00 (10 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    7.00 (7 / 1)

By jury 3 edit

  •  
    10.00 (10 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    9.00 (9 / 1)
  •  
    8.00 (8 / 1)
  •  
    8.00 (8 / 1)
  •  
    7.00 (7 / 1)
  •  
    5.00 (5 / 1)

Final ten (raw jury points) edit

Top 10 edit

still in discussion

Why this top 10 is different than raw top 10:

  • There are two images of the same author in top 3. It has been decided to forward the 4th place photographer (Botnaristefan) into top 3.
  • Botnaristefan's image representing a cross has little encyclopedic value and it would be better to have his waterfall image in the top 3 instead.
  • It is under debate whether we should better use Botnaristefan's photo of Parcul Național Orhei on 3rd place instead.
Retrieved from "https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Gikü/wle2016jury&oldid=242955482"