Open main menu

Wikimedia Commons β

The Nature Box

Joined 28 November 2013
Babel user information
en
ja-4
fr-2
Users by language

Greetings

I have been doing my best to contribute to Wikimedia since November 2013.

I also have a YouTube channel called The Nature Box.


          Using work released under a Share Alike Creative Commons license on YouTube

I have done quite a bit of research on whether or not it is OK to use work released under a Share Alike Creative Commons license (such as CC-BY SA 3.0) on YouTube, under a standard YouTube license. I believe it is OK, when sharing the original work. The reason is as follows:

  • CC-BY 3.0 licensed work can, without doubt, be shared on YouTube under a standard YouTube license. Kevin MacLeod's CC-BY 3.0 licensed work is one example of that. Note that on his website it says "YouTube's licenses are not related to licenses offered on this site" (meaning Kevin MacLeod's site, and CC-BY 3.0.) [1]
  • CC-BY 3.0 and CC-BY SA 3.0 are identical licenses, except for the part relating to derivative work, which the license calls an “Adaptation”. With the exception of songs used in video, the Share Alike section of Share Alike licenses applies only to derivative works. These are produced when the original work has been remixed, transformed, and built upon. Verbatim, or unaltered copies, are not derivative works. They are simply copies. And as long you comply with the other terms of the license (attribution etc.) you can make exact copies of an SA-licensed work without applying an SA license to the work in which it is used.
  • Sharing CC-BY SA work under YouTube’s CC license does not work well because YouTube’s CC license is CC-BY 3.0. [2]
  • I believe that there is no problem, either legally or indeed morally, with posting unchanged copies of work with a Share Alike license on YouTube. After all, the whole purpose of Creative Commons, the spirit of it, is to have work shared by others and made widely known to others.


  • Gallery



    Contributions

    Number of uploads Number of edits
    1,547 6,561

    Note: Figures are correct as of 19 May 2018. Source: Upload Counter by Pleclown.

    Awards

    Original Barnstar Hires.png The Original Barnstar
    In appreciation of all the wildlife videos you've uploaded. I've enjoyed seeing these and reviewing them. Keep 'em coming! INeverCry 23:12, 7 November 2015 (UTC)


    A kittenǃ Poké95 03:07, 24 January 2016 (UTC)

    Red Kitten 01.jpg