Data talk:Kuala Lumpur Districts.map
Latest comment: 6 years ago by Fæ in topic Sample Open Street Map coordinates in this data file
This data was nominated for deletion on 12 October 2017 but was kept. If you are thinking about re-nominating it for deletion, please read that discussion first. |
Created to raise DR. --Fæ (talk) 10:44, 12 October 2017 (UTC)
- Strong oppose. The uploader states that OSM was not used, and any reference to OSM has been removed from the files. Indeed, OSM copyright would only hold if the whole map boundaries were extracted from OSM and pasted into the Data file on Commons. This was not the case, because all maps in question depict Wikivoyage districts, which are invented and decided upon by the Wikivoyage community. Such district boundaries do not exist at OSM. Therefore, they are essentially drawn by hand. The author might have perused OSM as well as other maps when drawing the district boundaries, but none of the boundaries are taken from any external source.
- @Ymblanter, WhatamIdoing. --Alexander (talk) 12:15, 12 October 2017 (UTC)
Please make any comments or keep/delete opinions in the DR rather than here. Thanks --Fæ (talk) 13:21, 12 October 2017 (UTC)
Sample Open Street Map coordinates in this data file
edit- Data:(101.6596906, 3.1145888) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580464
- Data:(101.6526728, 3.1101407) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887001
- Data:(101.6508811, 3.1149401) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887002
- Data:(101.6505271, 3.1157864) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887003
- Data:(101.6501408, 3.1165042) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887005
- Data:(101.6498404, 3.1170184) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887007
- Data:(101.6494864, 3.1174684) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887009
- Data:(101.6492074, 3.1177469) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887011
- Data:(101.6488641, 3.1179933) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887013
- Data:(101.6484564, 3.1181754) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887015
- Data:(101.6478878, 3.1183575) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887017
- Data:(101.6473941, 3.1184553) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580467
- Data:(101.6453069, 3.1185693) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580469
- Data:(101.6438385, 3.1186575) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957600
- Data:(101.6437116, 3.1187534) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580471
- Data:(101.6435863, 3.1188731) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957599
- Data:(101.6434643, 3.1190632) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957598
- Data:(101.6434241, 3.1196016) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957597
- Data:(101.6434965, 3.1201506) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957601
- Data:(101.6441065, 3.1208351) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580475
- Data:(101.6481066, 3.1250671) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580477
- Data:(101.6483615, 3.1260753) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580478
- Data:(101.6481373, 3.126654) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580479
- Data:(101.647883, 3.1272514) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580480
- Data:(101.6470491, 3.1282235) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580485
- Data:(101.6464341, 3.1277216) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580483
- Data:(101.6457262, 3.1275397) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580482
- Data:(101.6446912, 3.1275108) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580481
- Data:(101.6437713, 3.1277758) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580484
- Data:(101.6403895, 3.1295851) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580487
- Data:(101.6385446, 3.1303833) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580488
- Data:(101.6371602, 3.131462) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580492
- Data:(101.6366216, 3.1318186) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580494
- Data:(101.6361197, 3.1320682) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580496
- Data:(101.6348734, 3.1323485) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580497
- Data:(101.6317081, 3.1316348) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580493
- Data:(101.630369, 3.1306962) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580491
- Data:(101.6300031, 3.1306056) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580490
- Data:(101.6294992, 3.1305895) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580489
- Data:(101.6292746, 3.1326296) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580498
- Data:(101.6296214, 3.1351764) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580501
- Data:(101.6296007, 3.136808) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580503
- Data:(101.629104, 3.1373507) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580504
- Data:(101.628069, 3.138012) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580506
- Data:(101.6271544, 3.1394086) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580507
- Data:(101.6261565, 3.1409386) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580508
- Data:(101.6253218, 3.1415494) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580511
- Data:(101.6248359, 3.1415503) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580510
- Data:(101.6233233, 3.1413027) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580509
- Data:(101.6213231, 3.1433364) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580513
- Data:(101.6199551, 3.1447125) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580514
- Data:(101.6192281, 3.1458206) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580516
- Data:(101.6187211, 3.1469526) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580518
- Data:(101.6173808, 3.1492228) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580520
- Data:(101.6164905, 3.1506222) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580522
- Data:(101.6151785, 3.152866) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580525
- Data:(101.615081, 3.1534803) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580527
- Data:(101.6152677, 3.158678) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580531
- Data:(101.6156169, 3.1607388) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580532
- Data:(101.6163601, 3.161347) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580535
- Data:(101.6165536, 3.1633401) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580539
- Data:(101.6160501, 3.1644449) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580540
- Data:(101.6161834, 3.1657988) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580543
- Data:(101.6165338, 3.1675584) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580544
- Data:(101.6166459, 3.168471) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580545
- Data:(101.6167597, 3.1701578) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580546
- Data:(101.6178152, 3.1710006) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580547
- Data:(101.6190405, 3.1740359) Source:mahau 2013-05-30 OSM node:2325070012
- Data:(101.6191681, 3.1821202) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580565
- Data:(101.619557, 3.1857576) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580570
- Data:(101.6198848, 3.1883939) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580573
- Data:(101.6190204, 3.1938579) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580577
- Data:(101.6188589, 3.195483) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580578
- Data:(101.6188486, 3.1962285) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580579
- Data:(101.6191165, 3.1979053) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580584
- Data:(101.6202478, 3.1974894) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580581
- Data:(101.6218987, 3.1975594) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580582
- Data:(101.6230345, 3.197846) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580583
- Data:(101.6239211, 3.198324) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580585
- Data:(101.6251656, 3.1995411) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580586
- Data:(101.6262049, 3.2011251) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580589
- Data:(101.6276245, 3.2036909) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580592
- Data:(101.6294006, 3.2085925) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580595
- Data:(101.6596906, 3.1145888) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580464
- Data:(101.6294006, 3.2085925) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580595
- Data:(101.6374012, 3.2320994) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580645
- Data:(101.6460737, 3.2321642) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580646
- Data:(101.6462036, 3.2335911) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580653
- Data:(101.6504911, 3.2337208) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580654
- Data:(101.654064, 3.234337) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580655
- Data:(101.6540965, 3.2368665) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580658
- Data:(101.6573446, 3.2360233) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580656
- Data:(101.6572471, 3.2372556) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580659
- Data:(101.6577993, 3.2413093) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580662
- Data:(101.659261, 3.2414066) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580663
- Data:(101.6611449, 3.2405958) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580660
- Data:(101.6611124, 3.2425416) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580664
- Data:(101.6635809, 3.2443252) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580666
- Data:(101.6659845, 3.2431901) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580665
- Data:(101.6682907, 3.2406931) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580661
Many of the above nodes are sourced on OSM as "Gov. MY". The source website http://www.data.gov.my/ releases map data under terms at http://www.data.gov.my/page/termsofuse. The terms include the requirement to link back to the terms and give an attribution. Consequently any map derived from the data cannot be CC0. --Fæ (talk) 11:58, 20 October 2017 (UTC)